Jujutsu Kaisen Episode Gets Amazing Rating But Fans Can’t Agree If It’s Good
Jujutsu Kaisen Season 3, Episode 4 is making news all around the world! It looks absolutely beautiful and has one of the highest ratings ever for the show. But here’s the interesting part: fans can’t agree if it’s actually good or not.
Some people say it’s the best episode ever. Others say it changed too much from the manga (the comic book version). Let’s understand what’s happening!
What’s Special About This Episode?
Episode 4 is all about Maki Zenin getting revenge on her mean family. It’s a really important moment in the story.
The episode has a 9.8 rating out of 10, with thousands of people voting for it! That’s one of the highest scores in the whole series.
The animation team took several manga chapters and turned them into one 28-minute episode. They changed some scenes and made the story feel different from the original manga.
This is where the arguments started.
Two Groups With Different Opinions
Right now, fans are split into two main groups:
Group 1: “This Looks Amazing!” These fans love how the episode looks. They think the fights are incredible, the animation is top-quality, and Maki looks super cool. They don’t mind if things are different from the manga as long as it’s exciting to watch.
Group 2: “This Changed Too Much!” These fans, especially many in Japan who read the manga, think the episode is too different. They say it focuses too much on looking cool and not enough on the sad emotions and story that made the manga special.
Why Japanese Fans Are Disappointed
Many Japanese manga readers are upset with this episode. Here’s why:
They feel the anime added too many new visual ideas that weren’t in the manga. For example, some fight scenes look like they’re from the movie “Kill Bill,” which is cool but not what the manga showed.
The main problem isn’t the animation quality (everyone agrees it looks great!). The problem is that the heavy, sad feelings from the manga don’t feel as strong in the anime.
One Japanese fan said that fans from other countries only care about “amazing animation” and “insane aura” (which means looking powerful and cool). They think these fans don’t care enough about careful storytelling.
Japanese fans also mentioned that an earlier episode explained the Culling Game rules in a simple way. Japanese fans liked that episode, but it got lower ratings from fans outside Japan who found it boring.
What Might Happen Next?
Some viewers are worried about the future. They’re afraid that because so many Japanese fans are unhappy, the animation studio might change how they make episodes.
This has happened before with other anime shows. One series had a “cinematic” style (like a movie) in its first season, but fans complained. So the studio went back to a simpler style that matched the manga more closely in later seasons.
Now people are asking big questions:
- Should anime try to please fans outside Japan who want exciting action?
- Or should anime focus on Japanese manga readers who want it to match the original story?
This isn’t just about one episode anymore. It’s about who anime is really made for!
What Fans Are Saying Online
Let’s look at what different fans are saying:
“Let Creators Be Free” Some fans say people complain too much about “backlash” (when lots of people don’t like something). They think if you don’t like how a show is made, just watch something else. Creators should be free to make their own choices.
“Episode 3 Was Boring” Another fan said Episode 3 was like reading a long, boring textbook. They even had to pause and look up the rules online because it was confusing. They think Episode 4 is great because it shows what animation can do that manga can’t.
“The Film Style is Beautiful” Some fans love that the studio uses movie-like techniques, creative scene changes, and strong visual storytelling. They think this season is brave and original. They see Maki’s journey as lonely and painful, which the animation shows perfectly.
“The Rating Proves It’s Good” Because this is the highest-rated episode, some fans say the opinions of people who only want manga accuracy don’t matter as much. The huge rating proves that most people love it!
“Some Fans Are Inconsistent” Other fans point out that some “manga purists” (people who want exact manga accuracy) are being unfair. These same fans supported an earlier episode that also changed things but now complain about this one. They say just reading information to the audience is bad storytelling whether it’s in manga or anime.
Understanding Both Sides
Here’s something important to remember: both groups of fans are right in their own way!
Manga readers want faithfulness because they love the original story so much. When you read something amazing, you want everyone else to experience it the same way. That makes sense!
Anime watchers want creativity because animation can do special things that manga can’t. Moving cameras, music, colors, and motion can make a story feel new and exciting. That makes sense too!
Instead of fighting, fans can talk about what they value most. Do you care more about emotions or action? Faithfulness or creativity? There’s no wrong answer—people just like different things!
Why This Debate is Actually Good
You might think all this arguing is bad, but it’s actually a good sign!
It shows that people really care about Jujutsu Kaisen. When fans have big conversations about a show, it means the show is important to them. That’s better than nobody caring at all!
The creators can learn from both sides. They can see that:
- Some fans want more emotional depth and faithfulness to the manga
- Other fans want bold, creative visual storytelling
If the creators listen to everyone carefully, they can find a balance. They can make episodes with powerful fights AND deep feelings. Then both manga readers and anime-only fans will be happy!
What Makes a Good Adaptation?
This episode makes us think about a tough question: what makes a good adaptation?
Is it being exactly like the manga? Some people say yes. If you change things, you might lose what made the original special.
Is it trying new ideas? Other people say yes. Animation is a different art form than manga, so it should use its own strengths.
The truth is probably somewhere in the middle. The best adaptations respect the original story while also doing creative things that only animation can do.
What Can We Learn?
Here are some important lessons from this whole debate:
Everyone Experiences Stories Differently: What feels perfect to one person might feel wrong to another. That’s okay! We all have different tastes.
Animation and Manga Are Different: They’re both art, but they use different tools. It’s hard to make them match perfectly.
Ratings Aren’t Everything: A 9.8 rating is amazing, but it doesn’t mean everyone agrees. Lots of people love it, but some people don’t, and both feelings are valid.
Caring Means Loving: When fans argue about a show, it’s because they love it. Nobody argues about shows they don’t care about!
Should You Watch Episode 4?
Yes! Definitely watch it and decide for yourself!
You might think it’s the best episode ever with amazing fights and beautiful animation. Or you might think it’s too different from the manga and missing some feelings. Or you might think it’s somewhere in between!
The best part about art is that you get to form your own opinion. Watch the episode, and see how it makes YOU feel. That’s more important than what anyone else says!
Final Thoughts
Jujutsu Kaisen Season 3, Episode 4 started one of the biggest debates in anime this year. It’s rated incredibly high, looks absolutely stunning, but has some manga readers feeling disappointed.
This debate shows us that stories can be told in many different ways. There’s no single “right” way to adapt a manga into anime. Different people want different things, and that’s what makes the conversation interesting!
Whether you love the episode or think it could be better, one thing is clear: Jujutsu Kaisen matters to a lot of people. And that’s something fans from all over the world can agree on!
